Company Info

Plummer Insurance is an independent insurance agency located located in Western Nebraska and Eastern Colorado. Our independent status allows us to partner with many different companies to tailor specific coverages to each person or business based on their individual, unique situation.

Since 1984, we have offered protection in auto, home, farm, health, life, business, trucks, crop, and bonds. Our local agents have many years of experience and come from many different backgrounds to help serve your insurance needs.

Our History

Plummer Insurance was established in 1984 by Steve and Helen Plummer, who purchased the agency from Eldon R Evers.

In January 2012, Plummer Insurance acquired Nerud Agency in Oshkosh, Nebraska, which gave them their second physical location.

In April, 2014, current owner, Andrew Plummer, purchased the agency from his parents, making him the second-generation family owner.

The agency acquired Valley Insurance Services and Western Insurance Services in July, 2015. The acquisition added locations in Bayard, Nebraska, Gering, Nebraska, and Fort Collins, Colorado.

The agency was formerly owned by the Bridgeport State Bank and was established in 1927. Thus, the agency has served the Nebraska panhandle area and Colorado front range for 90 years.

Today, the management and experienced staff at Plummer insurance are dedicated to serve nearly every insurance need and have contracted with many highly-rated companies to accomplish this goal. Whether you need to protect your auto, home, business, farm, crop, truck, life, or health, Plummer Insurance is here to service your needs.